Abstract
Waterborne diseases pose a significant global public health threat, particularly in sub-Saharan Africa, where frequent outbreaks occur. These diseases stemming from contaminated drinking water, poor waste management, and insufficient hygiene contribute to high morbidity and mortality in children under 5 years old. A study addressed waterborne diseases in N'Djamena, Chad's 3rd and 9th districts, through decision-making strategies. The research employed various methods, including a household survey using questionnaires, workshops, semi-structured interviews, and focus group discussions. Additionally, documentary research provided essential data for analysing the situation of diseases in the community. Epidemiological data from 2019- 2022 indicated a substantial prevalence of diseases such as diarrhoea, dysentery, skin infections, typhoid, abdominal pain, and malaria, with notable mortality, especially among children. Among surveyed households, 50% believed the consumed water was contaminated, attributing it to faecal matter, while 28% and 22% linked the diseases to inadequate hygiene and unsanitary conditions, respectively. The study advocates for comprehensive strategies, including improving water treatment efficiency, implementing safe waste management, promoting hygiene, and vaccination. Active involvement of all stakeholders, with municipal authorities leading, is crucial for effective implementation and combating waterborne diseases.
Author Contributions
Copyright © 2024 Daniel Mangueina, et al
Competing interests
The authors declare no conflict of interest.
Citation:
Introduction
Water is a precious resource vital to all life forms on our planet. Unfortunately, the ever- increasing use of freshwater worldwide has brought significant challenges. One of the most pressing issues is the deterioration of water quality due to rampant urbanisation and various human activities 126. Approximately 2.1 billion people, which is 30% of the world's population, lack access to safe drinking water at home—additionally, nearly 60% lack secure sanitation 14. By 2025, an estimated 3 billion people will live in water-stressed environments without adequate access to safe drinking water 10. The global situation in 2020 presented significant challenges for around 2 billion people who had to contend with issues such as using contaminated drinking water, inadequate handwashing facilities, and insufficient sanitation. These challenges had far-reaching consequences that could not be ignored 142.
Waterborne diseases caused by consuming contaminated water continue to pose a significant challenge worldwide, impacting both developed and developing countries. While it is true that less developed countries tend to report more cases, developed countries have also faced outbreaks of waterborne diseases 78. Each year, over 2.2 million people die from these diseases worldwide, with approximately 5.3% of the fatalities occurring among children under five years old 115. It has been estimated that there is an annual economic burden of around $1 billion in the United States alone, which can be attributed to these diseases 58. Ensuring access to safe drinking water is a significant challenge many African countries face today 90.
In Africa, only 22% of the population believes that they have access to adequate sanitation facilities 16. Additionally, a significant portion of the sub-Saharan African population, approximately 28%, practice open defecation, while 23% rely on "non-improved" sanitation facilities that may not meet optimal hygienic separation of faecal matter 78. Even where safe drinking water and secure toilets are available in Africa, a lack of awareness and mobilisation of proper hygiene practices continue to lead to waterborne disease outbreaks 6.
In Chad, the Ministry of Health and Prevention reports that diarrhoea is a significant concern for children under the age of 5, with an estimated nationwide prevalence of 17%. The incidence of diarrhoea is even higher in rural areas, where it affects 22% of children, compared to 10% in urban areas. It is important to note that each episode of diarrhoea can contribute to child malnutrition and impede growth. Diarrhoea has been linked to different pathogens and is often associated with water insecurity 59. The issues mentioned have tragic consequences, especially for disadvantaged populations, particularly women of childbearing age and children 17. Dr. Ahmat Moustapha, head of the Centre for the Prevention of Major Endemics in Chad, revealed that waterborne diseases claim the lives of roughly 19,000 children every year. Furthermore, these diseases are three times more prevalent in remote provinces than in urban areas. As a result, the Chadian government is burdened with an annual cost of approximately $25 million to manage and treat these illnesses in children.
According to Dr. Jean Bosco NDIHOKUBWAYO, the World Health Organization representative in Chad, healthcare accessibility in Chad is still quite limited, with only 28% of the population having access to it. Malaria continues to be the most pressing public health issue, leading to over 3000 deaths in Chadian hospitals in 2021 and accounting for 25.1% of morbidity in the general population. Tragically, it is also the leading cause of death in children under 5. Furthermore, the rapid demographic growth in N'Djamena presents significant challenges in effectively managing waste, wastewater, and faecal matter 1.
The absence of large-scale wastewater treatment systems and insufficient solid waste collection hinder sanitation efforts, posing severe risks to public health and the environment 73. The prevalence of waterborne diseases underscores the pressing need to improve the safety of drinking water and sanitation. Additionally, the healthcare industry is grappling with a dearth of qualified personnel and medical resources, emphasising the need for improvement. This study aimed to develop strategies for districts to combat waterborne diseases, focusing on their reduction, if not eradication, in the study area and other cities in Chad.
Materials and Methods
Study Area Description
N'Djamena, located in the Chari-Baguirmi province, is Chad's political capital and largest city. Established in April 1900 and designated as a district in 1919, it is located on the eastern bank of the Chari River, bordering Cameroon where the Logone and Chari rivers converge. The terrain is predominantly flat, with slight natural slopes. The city spans 39,500 hectares of urbanised areas, divided into ten municipal districts, and boasts a population of 1,390,309 residents, growing at an annual rate of 3.61% as of 2018. N'Djamena experiences distinct seasons, with a dry period from November to April and a rainy season from May to October. The climate registers an average maximum temperature of 44.1°C and a minimum of 23.8°C. Recent years have seen an annual rainfall range from 584 mm to 990 mm. The study primarily focused on the 3rd and 9th districts, positioned between 12°6'0'' and 12°0'0'' North latitude and between 15°2'0'' and 15°10'0'' East longitude. These districts are further divided into thirteen quarters: Ambassatna, Ardep Djoumal, Djambalbarh, Gardolé1, Kabalaye, Sabangali, Digangali, Gardolé 2, Kabé, Ngoumna, Ngueli, Toukra, and WaliaFigure 1
Figure 1.Geographical location of the 3rd and 9th districts of the city of N'Djamena (Republic of Chad)
Data collection
The research process unfolded through a meticulous methodology, encompassing a survey of 395 households, focus group discussions, direct observations, interviews with investigators utilising Android phones, exchanges with the mayors of two municipalities, personnel responsible for Water, Sanitation, and Hygiene (WASH), semi-structured interviews with health district officials, municipal delegates, neighbourhood leaders, institutional actors, and the Chadian Water Company (STE). This approach involved a diverse sample of 57 men, 97 women, 22 teenage girls, 10 male students, and 22 female students. Furthermore, testimonials and life narratives related to waterborne diseases were collected. The analysis of interviews was bolstered by referencing various documents, including reports, laws, legislative texts, Water Code data, municipal decrees, and other relevant research sources. Additionally, epidemiological data for 2019-2022 in the 3rd and 9th districts were obtained by scrutinising the daily consultation records of the Order of Malta Health Centre and the Mother and Child University Hospital. Data collection tools comprised household questionnaires, interview guides for key informants, and an observation checklist. This comprehensive methodological approach facilitated a profound understanding of the challenges and opportunities associated with water, sanitation, hygiene management, and waterborne diseases in the study area. It also promoted gathering diverse perspectives and expertise to enhance our analysis.
Ethical protocol
This research received approval from the Chad National Bioethics Committee (CNBT) in August 2022. It included a detailed protection protocol outlining potential risks throughout the survey's lifecycle. Verbal consent was obtained from each participant, who was individually interviewed. All participants were fully informed of the voluntary nature of their participation and the confidentiality and anonymity of the provided information. Furthermore, participants were informed of their right to refuse to answer any question, terminate the interview at any time, or even decline to participate in the survey altogether.
Legislative and Regulatory Framework
Chad has established vital regulations governing national environmental, health, water, and sanitation-hygiene policies. However, the primary challenge lies not in the quantity or quality of these regulations but in their practical implementation and oversight. Several noteworthy and relatively recent documents are particularly relevant to this research.
Law No. 014/PR/98 of August 17, 1998, outlines the fundamental principles of environmental protection, establishes the foundations of the national environmental protection policy, defines the principles of sustainable environmental management, and aims to prevent any degradation. Its objective is to safeguard and enhance natural resources and improve the population's living conditions.
DecreeNo.904/PR/PM/MERH/2009ofAugust6,2009,sets out regulations regarding environmental pollution and nuisances, clearly defining these issues. It also envisions the creation of a national technical committee responsible for monitoring and evaluating the implementation of international agreements related to pollution and nuisances. Furthermore, it establishes a coordination unit to oversee activities related to these issues and a technical control unit whose primary mission is to protect the environment against all forms of pollution and nuisances. Limited material and financial resources hinder the effective implementation of this implementing decree.
Texts related to Public Health
Law No. 014/PR/11 of February 28, 2011, establishes the Public Hygiene Code. This code defines the standards regarding environmental hygiene, sanitation of public spaces, food establishments, food items, water, industrial and commercial facilities, residences, swimming pools, educational institutions, healthcare facilities, public and private buildings, as well as the natural environment, even though their implementation remains non-existent due to the lack of adequate sanitary infrastructure enabling monitoring and control in accordance with the standard provisions stipulated in the Public Hygiene Code.
National Health Policy
The National Health Policy 2007-2015 was developed, validated, and adopted in May 2007 by all healthcare sector stakeholders and the Ministry of Health and Prevention. It is part of the government's social policy to provide quality healthcare services to the population. It provides healthcare professionals with a vision of healthcare development until 2015, with strategic directions tailored to the country's context. Unfortunately, the financial, material, and human resources did not align with this National Health Policy.
Texts related to Water and Sanitation
Law No. 16/PR/99 of August 18, 1999, establishes the Water Code, governing the management of river, lake, and groundwater, as well as hydraulic works, as determined by the provisions of this code, subject to compliance with international agreements. All national water resources are a collective asset, part of the state's public domain, inalienable, and imprescriptible. Their exploitation requires authorisation and must comply with existing laws and customary law.
Article 117 stipulates that prior authorisation is required for any action that may alter water quality. This code includes several sections dealing with sanitation. Historically, sanitation has been considered a complementary measure, implemented as part of other activities, such as disease control or the establishment of drinking water supply programs. However, the necessary material and financial resources are not always allocated adequately to ensure its effective implementation.
Decree No. 615/PR/PM/ME/MSP/2010 of August 2, 2010, defines quality standards for water intended for human consumption in Chad. Its purpose is to protect health by preventing adverse effects related to unsafe water. It applies to all water intended for human consumption in the Chadian territory, including bottled or other containers, except in certain circumstances. This decree does not cover natural mineral waters. Article 4 specifies that drinking water for human consumption must not harm consumers' health. It must not show signs of physicochemical, bacteriological, or biological pollution or contain toxic substances exceeding the standards established in the annexe to the decree. This decree is ineffective due to a lack of continuous monitoring of water quality: strict standards, treatment, awareness, and collaboration with health authorities to ensure the safety of drinking water.
The Decree No. 330/PR/PM/MEH/2010 of January 20, 2015, establishing the modalities for the transfer of state competencies to decentralised territorial authorities concerning the delegation of the public water service, has not been fully effective across the entire territory due to the absence of adequate accompanying measures.
The Drinking Water and Sanitation Master Plan (SDEA), established and adopted on April 30, 2003, with the support of UNDP-DAES, aims to achieve the access rate to potable water defined by the MDGs. However, this objective has not been achieved due to insufficient resources.
Municipal Orders
The N'Djamena City Hall issued two significant municipal orders to improve sanitary conditions in the city: Municipal Order No. 146/SG/DSTM/SUHA/96 of October 18, 1996, making the construction of family latrines mandatory, and MunicipalOrderNo.037/M/SG/DSTM/SHS/04ofFebruary17,2004, regulating the management of domestic, sewerage, and industrial wastewater in the municipality of N'Djamena. These two orders have not yielded the desired results in changing the population's behaviour because no preparatory activities were undertaken beforehand for their implementation. For example, awareness campaigns, mobilisation, accompanying measures, monitoring, evaluation, and material and financial resources are lacking or limited.
MunicipalOrderNo.145/M/SG/DSTM/SUHA/96ofOctober18,1996,prohibits open defecation. The real factors hindering the enforcement of this order include a lack of adequate sanitary infrastructure, insufficient hygiene awareness and education, financial constraints for the construction of proper toilets, and implementation issues due to a lack of proper oversight and sanctions.
Ordinance No. 014/PR/11 on the Hygiene Code
Article 3 of this ordinance outlines its fundamental principles. It states that any natural or legal person who produces or holds waste in conditions that may harm the soil, flora, or fauna, alter landscapes, pollute the air or water, generate noise or odours, and, in general, harm human, animal, and environmental health, is obligated to ensure or have ensured their disposal in accordance with the provisions of this law. However, this ordinance has implementation issues due to a lack of proper monitoring and adequate sanctions.
Institutional Framework
The Constitution of the Republic of Chad underscores the importance placed on safeguarding human health, the environment, water resources, sanitation, and hygiene. Dated March 31, 1996, and subsequently revised in 2005, 2018, and 2020, it explicitly lays out the following principles:
· Every individual has the right to a healthy environment (Article 47) ;
· The State and decentralised authorities have to ensure environmental protection (Article 48) ;
· The transportation, importation, storage, disposal, or discharge of toxic or polluting substances are strictly prohibited in Chad.
The rigorous implementation of laws and regulations governing environmental protection, water, hygiene, and sanitation will significantly contribute to public health protection and the sustainable preservation of our environment while enhancing food security for the population. This will involve the collection and treatment of solid waste, faecal matter, secure wastewater, and rainwater, as well as the treatment of industrial wastewater, thereby ensuring water security. Furthermore, information campaigns on the Hygiene Code, implementing decrees, and establishing a health police force will be necessary to safeguard the population against waterborne diseases and other health risks. These efforts must be undertaken with determination and consistency to ensure a healthier future for all.
Results and Discussions
Categorisation of Water-Related Diseases
Waterborne diseases arise due to deteriorating hygiene and sanitary controls 41. These illnesses can be triggered by various microorganisms, such as bacteria, viruses, and parasites 64.
"Water-related diseases" refer to those contracted through ingestion or direct contact or diseases in which water is the habitat for larvae or parasites 94. Categorising water- induced diseases is crucial for assessing public health risks, aiming to classify and understand diseases related to water contamination, whether by pathogens, chemicals, or other contaminants 60. These diseases can have severe consequences for human health, and their categorisation is essential for implementing effective water management, prevention, control, and treatment strategies. However, these diseases can be broadly classified into three categories based on their health implications concerning water: waterborne diseases, vector-borne diseases linked to water, and waterborne-origin diseases 65.
Waterborne Diseases
Waterborne diseases, or water-related illnesses, are infections caused by the consumption or contact with water contaminated by pathogens such as bacteria, viruses, parasites, or other microorganisms 8. They pose a significant health concern in many regions of the world, especially in developing countries where access to safe drinking water is limited and often associated with poor hygiene and sanitation conditions 133. Preventing waterborne diseases involves improving the supply of clean drinking water, ensuring proper sanitation facilities, educating people about personal hygiene, and administering vaccines when possible 36. Treatment depends on the specific disease but may include rehydration, the administration of antibiotics or antiparasitic drugs, and other supportive measures 21. It is important to note that waterborne diseases can be deadly, especially in malnourished individuals or those with weakened immune systems (Ali, 2023). Therefore, proper prevention and management are essential to reduce the impact of these diseases on public health.
Water-Related Vector-Borne Diseases
Water-related vector-borne diseases are infections caused by pathogens such as bacteria, viruses, or parasites that are transmitted by aquatic organisms, such as mosquitoes,flies,fleas, or mollusks117. They remain a significant challenge in many regions, particularly developing countries where access to clean water and sanitation is limited 112. Diseases like malaria (transmitted by the Anopheles mosquito) and dengue (transmitted by the Aedesmosquito) continue to inflict considerable suffering, with these vectors finding their breeding grounds in aquatic environments 79. Changes in habitats and climatic conditions can promote mosquito proliferation and the spread of these diseases 19. It is important to note that the prevention and control of these diseases often depend on improving access to clean drinking water, vector management, sanitation, and health education 35. This study will be limited to waterborne diseases. Table 1
Table 1. Some of the primary waterborne or water-related diseases observed in ChadDiseases | Causative agent(s) | Geographic area | Number of cases per year | Deaths per year | The number of cases per year in the study area. | Deaths per year in the study area | References |
Hepatitis A | The virus spreads through the faecal- oral route via contam inated water, food, and person-to-person contact | On a global scale | 354 million | 7134 deaths (which represents 0.5% of the mortality attributed to viral hepatitis) in 2016 | 5% within the population. | 8 deaths | ( WHO.2020;Uwis hema et al., 2022) |
Amoebic dysentery Bacillary dysentery | Caused by bacteria such as Shigella or Entamoeba histolytica, they are transmitted through the faecal-oral route, either by using contaminated water or food or through directperson-to-person contact. | On a global scale | 500 million per year. | 17% of dysentery cases were in Chad, and 2908 were in the study area. | 15 deaths among children aged 0-5 years. | (Guenzi et al., 2023;Abdullah Sabeeh & Khalaf, 2022) | |
Typhoid and Paratyphoid | Caused by Salmonella enterica serovar Typhi (S. Typhi) and Salmonella enterica serovar Paratyphi (S.Paratyphi), this condition is primarily initiated by S. Typhi and S. ParatyphiA and B (and, occasionally, S.Paratyphi C), spreading through the faecal-oral route via contaminated water, food, or person-to-person contact. | Asia, Latin America, Africa | 11-21million cases compared to 6 million cases of paratyphoid fever | 128,000 to161,000 deaths from Typhoid and 54,000 deaths from Paratyphoid | In 1953, there were cases in the study area. | 35 deaths | (Careyet al.,2023; OMS,2018; WHO.2018) |
Gastroenteritis | Gastroenteritis is typically transmitted through contam inated water or food, whether bacterial, viral, or caused by internal parasites, protozoa, orpathogenic amoebas. | On a global scale | 3 to 5 billion | 2 million deaths | 275 deaths in the city of N'Djamena | 69 deaths in the study area | (WHO.2017;(Hellysaz etal.,2023) |
Diarrheal diseases | Caused by various microorganisms such as bacteria, viruses, or parasites, this infection spreads through contaminated water or food, as well as from person to person in cases of poorhygiene | On a global scale | 4 billion | 485,000 deaths | In 2019, 4.45%of the population and 3,948 cases were recorded in the study area. | 26 deaths in the study area | (WHO.2017; WHO.2017) |
Malaria | Caused by parasites of the genus Plasmodium and is transmitted by the bite of the female anopheles (Anophelessp.). | Africa, Southeast Asia, India, South America | 247 million in total, the vast majority (228million, or 95%) in Africa. | 627,000 deaths,96% of which(602,000) will be in Africa by 2021 | 21096 cases in the study area | 3000 deaths in Chad and 267 deaths in the study area | (OMS, 2022; OMS, 2015; OMS/CHA D.2023) |
Cholera | Caused by the bacterium Vibrio cholerae and spreads mainly through contaminated water and food. by the faeces of an infected person (faecal- oral transmission) | South America, Africa, Asia | 1.3 - 4million | 21,000 to 14,300deaths | 450 cases inChad in 2017 | 59 deaths in Chad in 2017 | (Trolle et al., 2023; OMS,2017) |
Poliomyelitis | The virus spreads by following the faeco-oral route, using contaminated water, foodstuffs or person-to-person contact as vectors. | India, Near East, Asia, and West and Central Africa | 12 | 3 | 115 from 2019 to2020 | more than 80 children paralysed in Chad | (OMS/CH AD.2023; WHO,2021;Liu et al., 2023;OMS,2020) |
Water-Origin Diseases
The section aims to elucidate the concept of water-origin diseases and assess their severity in developing nations. The National Institute of Public Health of Quebec defines water-origin diseases as infectious or physicochemical ailments caused or presumed to be caused by water ingestion, contact, or inhalation. Pathogenic microorganisms like bacteria, viruses, parasites, and protozoa are common culprits, spreading through contaminated water, skin contact, or ingesting food prepared with untreated water 104. Populations lacking access to safe water, sanitation, and hygiene practices are particularly vulnerable, as untreated faecal matter can contaminate freshwater sources and food 62. Notable water-origin diseases include cholera, typhoid, polio, dysentery, diarrhoea, and hepatitis A and B. Humans and animals host these pathogens 119.
The World Health Organization reports that around 2 billion people globally rely on water contaminated by faecal matter, posing a substantial risk to public health. Water-Origin Diseases are a significant challenge in developing countries, leading to high morbidity and mortality, especially among children under 5. Diarrheal diseases, with an estimated 1.7 billion cases annually, rank as the second leading cause of death in this age group worldwide 119. Developing nations bear the brunt, with 18% of under-five deaths attributed to these diseases, predominantly in Africa and Southeast Asia 123. Poor water quality and inadequate sanitation result in approximately 297,000 annual deaths in children under 5 due to diarrheal diseases 86. Disposing of human waste in open areas exacerbates the issue, contributing to microbiological contamination of water 126. Crucially, prevention hinges on enhancing access to clean water and adopting proper hygiene and sanitation practices. Addressing these challenges is vital to curbing the impact of water- origin diseases and improving public health in vulnerable communities.
The Transmission of Water-Related Diseases
Waterborne diseases primarily spread through drinking water or surface water contamination by pathogens (bacteria, viruses, parasites, chemicals) 77. Transmission pathways include ingesting contaminated water, skin contact, consuming contaminated food, exposure to wastewater, transmitting through vectors such as flies, and lacking personal hygiene 94.
The key factors contributing to the proliferation of waterborne communicable diseases
The main factors contributing to the proliferation of waterborne diseases include: Household hygiene: Poor hygiene in both individual and collective settings in disadvantaged areas facilitates pathogen transmission 32, 117 Socioeconomic status of households: Precarious living conditions, such as overcrowding and close quarters, increase the risk of contagion 129; Community living (markets, churches, hospitals, etc.): Gatherings in these environments can promote disease spread without adequate hygiene and prevention measures 131 Quality of the drinking water supply network: Inadequate control of distributed water can lead to pathogen contamination 56; Limited access to safe drinking water: Using untreated water raises the risk of waterborne diseases 78; Inadequate water treatment and monitoring: Poor water treatment and insufficient quality monitoring expose the population to health risks 57; Lack of health education: Insufficient awareness about personal hygiene, water purification, and environmental health also contributes to disease transmission 142 Overpopulation and population density: High population density can facilitate disease spread due to inadequate healthcare infrastructure to meet the population's needs 38, 117; Failures in pumps, pipelines, and water purification facilities can expose populations to risks of waterborne diseases 78; The lack of hygiene in washing vegetables and fruits before consumption, coupled with persistent community conflicts associated with certain beliefs and practices, are major factors contributing to the transmission of waterborne diseases 15, 24.
The Environmental Impacts of Hygiene, Sanitation, and Sanitary Practices
The environmental impacts of hygiene, sanitation, and sanitary practices are a major global concern, leading to significant repercussions on public health and the planet's sustainability 88. Within the study area, observations reveal substantial quantities of solid and liquid waste scattered in streets, open spaces, gutters, and depressions. Among these wastes, biodegradable materials such as plant debris, leaves, branches, food remnants, and non- biodegradable items like plastic bags, packaging, tin cans, and glass bottles negatively affect the environment 33. Furthermore, the presence of faecal matter in depressions, open spaces, and unregulated dumps, along with the untreated discharge of domestic wastewater and flush toilet effluents into stormwater drainage channels, intensifies soil and groundwater contamination, compromising water quality and biodiversity 4. These wastes also detrimentally affect the living environment by emitting foul odours, while the proliferation of insects and rodents threatens residents' health (Suare Marcillo, 2012). Waterborne diseases, stemming from various factors such as contamination of drinking water, non-adherence to hygiene practices, the use of communal toilets, and the disposal of anthropogenic waste into water, spread throughout the districts 118. Faced with these challenges, it is imperative to implement sustainable solutions involving effective management of potable water supply systems, improved hygiene practices, safe waste collection and disposal, promotion of modern sanitation facilities, and raising awareness of chemical risks. These measures will contribute to preserving public health and the environment, maintaining optimal sanitary conditions.
Analysis of the Situation
Unsafe water pollution has severe consequences on human health. According to the UNESCO World Water Development Report in 2021, approximately 829,000 people lose their lives annually due to waterborne diseases caused by non-potable water, lack of sanitation, and poor hand hygiene 25. Among these deaths, nearly 300,000 are children under the age of five, accounting for 5.3% of all deaths in this age group 13. However, in the study area, almost the entire population (99.8%) exclusively consumed water from taps and hand-powered pumps (PMH). The quality of this water is mainly compromised by the contamination of two physicochemical parameters (temperature and ammonium) and two bacteriological parameters (total coliforms and total aerobic flora), leading to a high prevalence of waterborne diseases. Furthermore, concerning tap water consumption, purified water, and bottled water, it has been established that tap water is a significant source of gastrointestinal diseases 80, 122, hindering nutrient absorption and causing malnutrition 113. These findings align with those in Palestine, where individuals consuming municipal water directly face a higher risk of waterborne diseases such as diarrhoea than those using desalinated and filtered drinking water at the household level 5. These effects are particularly pronounced in children 124. According to epidemiological data from 2019 to 2022 obtained from the Order of Malta Health Centre in Wallia and the Mother and Child University Hospital in Gardolé, a significant
prevalence of water-related diseases has been recorded among women of childbearing age and children aged 0 to 5. These diseases primarily include diarrhoea (3948 cases), dysentery (2908 cases), skin infections (650 cases), typhoid (1953 cases), abdominal pains (1250 cases), and malaria (21096 cases). It is also concerning to note the number of deaths associated with these diseases, including 267 deaths from severe malaria, 69 deaths of gastrointestinal origin among children aged 0 to 5, and 103 deaths due to typhoid fever. Pathogens can also transmit these diseases from inadequate sanitation facilities, unfavourable piping conditions, and water supply system architecture conducive to the growth of microorganisms 110, even within the microbial communities present in drinking water distribution systems, leading to waterborne diseases 56. Consumption of contaminated water, open defecation, ruptures, or leaks can trigger low-pressure events, and when repaired, pathogens can enter the systems 40, 76. Additionally, the lack of adequate services for the disposal of faecal matter, solid and liquid waste, and climatic conditions plays a crucial role in epidemics 78. Climate can introduce contaminants into water sources through runoff during intense precipitation or floods 147. Moreover, temperature variations ranging from 30-45 °C can alter the dynamics of microbes in pipelines, and pathogens present can be released into moving water 20, along with inadequate hygiene practices. All these factors support the obtained results, revealing that most surveyed households attribute these diseases to poor drinking water quality (50%), inadequate hygiene practices (28%), and unsanitary conditions (19%). In comparison, others (3%) could not provide a specific response to this question.
These two districts face inadequate healthcare systems due to various socio-economic reasons. Thus, this area will bear a heavy burden in terms of morbidity by the end of 2022, with an observed increase in cases of waterborne diseases. Unfortunately, most of the budget allocated to the health, water, and sanitation sectors is mainly invested in poorly designed or unfinished water projects, leading to groundwater pollution 109. Moreover, a significant portion of these funds is allocated to purchasing medications and operating various technical services 37. However, the misappropriation of public funds has reached alarming levels in this environment 94. Preventive measures have not been implemented, such as hygiene promotion, mobilisation, awareness, and accompanying actions to alleviate the populations affected by these diseases 124. Furthermore, collaboration to reduce or eradicate high-morbidity waterborne diseases has not been undertaken between different districts of the city of N'Djamena in partnership with development actors. A more coordinated approach and cooperation between districts and stakeholders could significantly mitigate this urgent public health issue 142.
Adhering to the following recommendations can significantly mitigate or eliminate the risk of waterborne communicable diseases:
Water treatment for consumption
In the study area, drinking water treatment poses a significant challenge due to limited resources and constraints on access to energy for boiling-based disinfection. Therefore, we advocate and strongly encourage the adoption of simpler, cost-effective, and less energy-intensive alternative techniques.
Chlorination
Ensuring a safe and clean water supply is the most crucial preventive measure to reduce the risk of waterborne diseases 41. Free chlorine has proven to be the most widely used and practical disinfectant for purifying water intended for human consumption 82. It is an effective and cost-efficient method for eliminating pathogenic microorganisms in water, such as bacteria and viruses, except for Cryptosporidium spp and certain species of mycobacteria (Bloom & Reenan, 2013). Adding just a few milligrams of free chlorine per litre of water for about thirty minutes generally inactivates nearly 100% of enterobacteria and viruses 52. In addition to disinfection, chlorination can also contribute to maintaining water quality by preventing the growth of algae and bacteria in drinking water distribution systems 56. This helps prevent biofilm formation and ensures clean water throughout the distribution network 144. However, it is crucial to monitor and manage the process to minimise undesirable effects, such as by-product formation 105. When chlorine reacts with organic matter in water, it can produce by-products such as trihalomethanes (THMs), which can harm health at high concentrations 82. Thus, ensuring the supply of high-quality drinking water requires careful management of these processes.
These WHO guidelines may vary depending on local conditions, water characteristics, and other factors. Table 2
Table 2. Chemical agents and contact times for making drinking water potableChemical agents | Dose | Contact time in minutes |
Sodium hypochlorite (commonly known as bleach): NaOCl | 0.5 -2.0 (mg/L) | 30-60 |
Aquatabs® | 1 tablet: 3.5 mg per litre | 30 |
Solar Disinfection
Filters
Water filters prevent waterborne diseases by removing contaminants and making drinking water safer 35. Using activated carbon or membrane filters can render water potable and safe for consumption 87. Therefore, to ensure that water remains clean and safe for drinking, it is essential to store it in suitable containers equipped with taps to prevent any subsequent contamination 23. It is important to note that the effectiveness of water filters can vary depending on the quality of the water source and regular filter maintenance 43. It is highly recommended for health authorities and water management experts in municipalities to conduct a thorough assessment to determine the most suitable filtration system 44. Furthermore, the selected filters must be certified to meet the water quality standards established by the World Health Organization and the national guidelines of Chad.
The filter featured in Figure 2 is available in certain outlets and is occasionally offered at affordable prices in local markets in Ndjamena. We recommend promoting, subsidising by the government, and utilising it in the study area after the health regulatory services approve it.
Moringa Wood
Measures to be taken for Containers Intended for Household Drinking Water Storage
The grant or free distribution of water containers, cooking pots, and fuel in sufficient quality and quantity to the most impoverished households should play a significant role in reducing the risk of diseases such as typhoid fever, dysentery, diarrhoea, and more. This would ensure the preservation of stored clean water and the proper preparation of food 66.
Optimising the Quality of Drinking Water
To monitor and collect data on drinking water quality provided by the Chadian Water Company (STE), it is imperative to establish a real-time monitoring system for water quality indicators using sensors 112. These sensors should be installed at the most frequently used water fountains 143. The data collected will then be used to quickly detect abnormal fluctuations in water quality, allowing for effective intervention in resolving the issue of drinking water contamination 74. For frequently used human-powered pumps (HPPs), municipalities should be equipped with portable rapid analysis kits to determine precisely the water quality consumed by households in their jurisdictions 131. This will require training WASH agents, well operators, and water point managers on sensor data handling and interpretation and using these portable analysis kits 67. Based on the collected data, targeted interventions can be planned, such as water treatment, water point disinfection, distribution of hygiene kits, geolocation of clean water distribution points, and identification of high-risk areas 71. Based on the collected data, targeted interventions can be planned, such as water treatment, water point disinfection, distribution of hygiene kits, geolocation of clean water distribution points, and identification of high-risk areas 91. Regular meetings should be organised to plan and coordinate interventions, including the temporary or permanent closure of heavily polluted or contaminated water points, among other measures 46 . Additionally, municipal authorities must routinely monitor drinking water quality and take immediate action to address identified issues.
Health Education
Health education is vital in preventing and eradicating water-related diseases in our study area, which faces significant health challenges due to the quality of drinking water and sanitation 12. To combat these diseases effectively, it is imperative to raise awareness among the population about good hygiene practices, proper sanitation, and responsible water management 142. Here are some key points to consider:
Awareness of the Importance of Clean Drinking Water
Households need to be informed about the risks associated with consuming untreated water from unreliable sources like the Logone and Chari rivers and the benefits of having access to safe drinking water 72.
Promotion of Basic Sanitation
Personal hygiene and waste management are crucial to prevent waterborne diseases 78. Educational programs should promote using latrines, proper excreta disposal, and regular handwashing, especially before meals and after using the toilet 126. Disinfecting excreta with cresol sodium without a sewage system and fly control is a vital concern for hygiene and public health 90.
Training healthcare professionals and peer educators.
Access to Information
Community Engagement
Active involvement of residents in planning and implementing health education programs is crucial, as households must be encouraged to improve their health conditions by taking responsible steps for positive behaviour change 11.
Monitoring and Evaluation
Collecting data on hygiene practices, waterborne disease rates, and progress in implementing health education programs is crucial to measuring the impact of interventions and making necessary adjustments 50. Health education will be vital in combating waterborne diseases 31. Providing accurate information and promoting proper hygiene practices can significantly reduce the spread of these diseases and improve the quality of life for vulnerable populations 61. However, this approach must be supported by investments in water infrastructure and sanitation to achieve sustainable results 41. Table 3
Table 3. Institutional Strategy for Excreta and Wastewater ManagementDistricts | ||
---|---|---|
Excreta and wastewater | ||
Methods and Techniques for the Sanitary Disposal of Excreta and Wastewater | ||
Level 1 | Improved Toilets | Disposal of Excreta and Greywater Separately |
Level2 | Condominium CollectionNetworks | Disposing of Excreta and Greywater Together |
Responsibilities | Coordination: The central city hall | |
Housekeeping - Mason - Septic Tank Cleaner | ||
Ministry of the Environment, Fisheries, and Sustainable Development (MEFSD) - Ministry of Water and Sanitation (MWS) - Ministry of Territorial Administration, Decentralization, and Good Governance (MTADGG) - Ministry of Infrastructure and Decongestion (MID) - Ministry of Territorial Planning, Housing, and Urban Development(MTPHUD) | ||
Financing | Level 1 | Households - Non-Governmental Organizations(NGOs) - Donors - Individuals - Neighborhoods |
Level 2 | The State and its development partners | |
Priority | 1-Level 1 | |
2-Level 2 | ||
Goaltoachieve | Reducing the risk of contact between excreta and the population while eliminating sources of contamination, such as stagnant water, is vital forpreserving public health. | |
Protecting the receiving environment and groundwater to ensureefficient capture of water supply systems for the production of safe drinking water | ||
Reuse | ||
Securing collection networks and ensuring effective treatment prior todischarge into the receiving environment |
At the Institutional Level
The STE and the personnel responsible for water supply and sanitation in municipalities must ensure compliance with hygiene standards at water distribution points and fountains following the requirements specified in the contract with water point operators in all districts 107. Municipal authorities responsible for WASH should incorporate water code requirements into company contracts 67. These requirements should become critical elements from the infrastructure design and construction phase, such as small-scale water supply systems and sanitation facilities 115. This approach will ensure the effective implementation of water-related standards and regulations, delivering high-quality WASH services to households 27. Municipal authorities should enhance the skills of water supply technicians and well managers in sanitation and water hygiene to maintain the quality of drinking water produced 67. Establishing ongoing cross-sector collaboration, particularly between the fields of hydraulics and health, is of paramount importance. Active involvement of municipalities remains essential for achieving these objectives 41. Standardising the technical inspection methods employed in the hydraulic sector, including an online component for accessing these standards and procedures 92.
Condominium Collection Networks
The study area is facing significant challenges in managing excreta and wastewater. These challenges are exacerbated due to its rapid growth and urbanisation, necessitating an innovative and sustainable approach to address this issue 107. That is why we propose the condominium network. The condominium network is a wastewater management system that collects, treats, and reuses wastewater at the neighbourhood level 30. It is an integrated approach that efficiently and cost-effectively manages excreta and wastewater, with the potential solution being implementing condominium wastewater management networks while minimising environmental impacts 68.
Key advantages of the condominium network compared to the conventional model include:
Efficient collection of wastewater using an underground pipeline network;
Treatment of collected wastewater locally in treatment plants tailored to the population size served 51
Reuse of treated water for irrigation, landscaping maintenance, or safe discharge into the environment, contributing to water resource conservation 34.
More cost-effective to implement and maintain, making it more accessible for rapidly growing urban communities 3.
Community participation: Encourages active involvement of residents in the system's management and maintenance, strengthening a sense of community responsibility and ownership 26.
Each block comprises 30-40 households 48.
The operation of this system will be the responsibility of autonomous municipalities led by a Condominium Committee, and its maintenance will be ensured by the same committee 127.
Regarding Municipal Responsibility
Responsibilities for solid waste management include collection, sorting, recycling, and environmentally responsible disposal of waste 34. Municipal authorities must establish adequate infrastructure, such as sorting centres and sanitary landfills, and develop regulations to encourage source reduction and public awareness 84. In the case of excreta and wastewater, ensuring proper sanitation systems is essential 106. This includes constructing and maintaining sewage networks and wastewater treatment plants and promoting improved household toilets 45. The primary responsibility in this area also falls on local authorities, working in collaboration with public health stakeholders, to establish the following coordination and management structure 28.
Sources of Financing
Securing funding for these initiatives is a substantial challenge. The study area is proposed to explore various funding sources, including government funds such as budgetary support and municipal grants 108. Public-private partnerships focusing on sanitation projects and support from NGOs and associations are also viable options 42. Another avenue is seeking international grants from organisations like AFD (French Development Agency) and BAD (African Development Bank). Creating a dedicated fund for sanitation management is also suggested 115. This fund could be fuelled by diverse means, including waste and habitat taxes, infrastructure usage fees, and voluntary contributions from businesses and citizens 83. This diversified approach would mobilise varied financial resources, ensuring a robust foundation for the sustainable financing of sanitation initiatives 18. Table 4
Institutional Strategy for Managing Waterborne Diseases in Healthcare Centres and Hospitals
Waterborne diseases pose a significant public health challenge in Chadian cities, affecting children aged 0-5 years and the entire population, irrespective of social class (Guarango, 2022). Their impact is reflected in high annual prevalence rates, hospitalisations, and, unfortunately, fatalities. The coordinated and sustainable management of waterborne diseases in healthcare centres and hospitals 103, especially in vulnerable areas like the 3rd and 9th districts of N'Djamena, requires the implementation of effective institutional strategies, despite limited resources, to mitigate their impact on public health 39. Here are some suggested solutions:,Table 5
Table 4. Institutional Strategy for Managing Rain waterDistricts | |
---|---|
Rainwater | |
Methods and Techniques for Rainwater Drainage | |
Level 1 | Construction of drainage channels in front of residences |
Level 2 | Condominial collection networks |
Responsibilities | coordination: The central city hall |
State - Municipality - Neighbourhoods - Households | |
Ministry of Environment, Fisheries, and Sustainable Development (MEFSD) - Ministry of Water and Sanitation (MWS) - Ministry of Infrastructure and Decongestion (MID) - Ministry of Land Planning,Housing, and Urban Development (MLPHUD) | |
Financing | State and its development partners |
State grant to municipalities - Household (Waiving property tax fees for households for two years inconnection with the construction of drainage channels in neighbourhoods)-Funders-Donors | |
Priority | 1-Level 1 |
2-Level 2 | |
Goal to achieve | Minimise impact, reduce run-off, and evacuate rainwatersafely. |
Districts | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Solid Waste Generation at the Community Level | ||||||
Methods and Techniques for Solid Waste Elimination | ||||||
Level1 | Environmental Education: Implementing educational programs to raise awareness among the population about the environmental impacts of solidwaste and promoting responsible behaviours | |||||
Level2 | Strict Regulation: The implementation of the application decree for the stringent sanitation code aims to oversee waste management and enforceenvironmental standards for both businesses and municipalities | |||||
Level3 | Incineratio n | Composti ng | Primary collectio n (initial househol d waste collection) and secondary collectio n (sorting and grouping of waste) | Tertiary collection (it transports non- recyclable waste to its final destination while adhering to environment al regulations) | Secure Treatmen t- Disposal | Transformatio n- Recycling |
Level4 | Circular Economy: Promoting the adoption of circular economic models whereproducts are designed to be recycled, repaired, or reused, thereby minimising waste generation | |||||
Responsibilities | Coordination: The central city hall | |||||
Ministry of Environment, Fisheries, and Sustainable Development (MEFSD) - Ministry of Water and Sanitation (MWS) - Ministry of Territorial Administration, Decentralization, and Good Governance (MTADGG) - Ministry of Infrastructure and Decongestion (MID) - Ministry of Territorial Planning, Housing, and Urban Development (MTPHUD)-Households-Municipalities | ||||||
Financing | Households-Municipalities-Ministry of Vocational Training, Trades, and Microfinance (MFPMM) - Ministry of Youth and Entrepreneurial Leadership(MJLE) | |||||
Financial aid from the State to municipalities - Development partners - Non- Governmental Organizations (NGOs) - Private and Semi-governmentalEnterprises - Associations, etc. | ||||||
Priority | 1 | 1 | 1 | 2 | 2 | 3 |
Goal to achieve | Eliminate all sources of contamination between waste and the population toensure water safety and public health. | |||||
Promoting on-site recycling | ||||||
Promote the transformation and reuse of materials at the end of their lifecycle. |
Vaccinations
Due to the high prevalence of waterborne diseases in the study area, it would be desirable for households to be vaccinated per the 141 recommendations. These guidelines emphasise the crucial role of vaccinations against waterborne diseases in preventing potentially severe infections 77. Figure 3
Figure 3.WASH-Health Management Coordination Plan
Cholera: The oral cholera vaccine (OCV) and Vaxchora are recommended 77.
Typhoid: The injectable Typhim (Vi) and the oral Vivotif (Ty21a) vaccines are recommended 77.
Polio: The oral attenuated virus vaccine (OPV) and the inactivated vaccine (IPV) have played a significant role in nearly eradicating the disease 29.
Hepatitis A: The vaccine against hepatitis A (Avaxim, Epaxal, etc.) is recommended 146. Figure 5
Hepatitis B: The vaccine against hepatitis B (Engerix-B, Heplisav-B, etc.) is recommended 69. Figure 4
Figure 4.Waterborne Disease Management Plan in Hospitals and Health Centers
Figure 5.Action plan aimed at combating waterborne diseases in the study area
Conclusion
Water, an essential resource often underestimated, is crucial for every human being on Earth. However, its significance is marred by its role as a vector for pathogens like bacteria, viruses, and parasites. This has led to a growing concern, prompting efforts to analyse and treat water before consumption. Despite the willingness to access safe drinking water, its cost remains a barrier, compelling many to rely on available sources. Water-related diseases, especially impacting women of reproductive age and children under 5, continue to be a leading cause of global death and illness, particularly in sub-Saharan Africa.
To address this challenge, decision-makers must invest wisely in sustainable infrastructure in water, sanitation, and health sectors for optimal public health outcomes. Transparency and community participation are vital for success, fostering health education and resilience to water- related health risks. This approach creates awareness about water's importance in daily life and the preservation of the immediate environment. The multidimensional and collaborative approach, with active involvement from the local population, is crucial for the long-term success of eradicating waterborne diseases in the 3rd and 9th districts of Ndjamena.
Funding body
This research study received no external funding.
References
- 1.A, Kadjangaba E, Léontine T, Bongo D, D Mbaigane Jean-Claude. (2022) . Evaluation of Quality Borehole Water Consumed in Public Schools in N’Djamena City (Chad).JournalofEnvironmentalScienceandEngineeringA,11(5) 10-17265.
- 2.Sabeeh Abdullah, F, A K Khalaf. (2022) Molecular diversity for Entamoeba histolytica virulence factor genes isolated from patients with amoebic dysentery. , Biochemical and Cellular Archives 22(2), 3441-3448.
- 3.I R Abubakar, M S Alshammari. (2023) Urban planning schemes for developing low- carbon cities in the Gulf Cooperation Council region. , Habitat International 138, 102881-10.
- 4.I R Abubakar, K M Maniruzzaman, U L Dano, F S AlShihri, M S AlShammari et al. (2022) . Environmental Sustainability Impacts of Solid Waste Management Practices in the Global South.InternationalJournalofEnvironmentalResearchandPublicHealth,19(19) 12717-10.
- 5.H T AbuEltayef, K S AbuAlhin, K M Alastal. (2023) Addressing non-revenue water as a global problem and its interlinkages with sustainable development goals.Water Practice &Technology. https://doi.org/10.2166/wpt.2023.157
- 6.P S Africa, S D Goals, I S Africa. (2001) sanitation and health South Africa ’ sremainingand existing issues. 25-34.
- 8.Allaq A A A, H, E B Yahya, A M Saleh, N J Sidik et al. (2023) Emerging Drinking Water Borne Diseases: A Review on Types. Sources and Health Precaution.Journal of PharmaceuticalResearchInternational,35(31) 1-17.
- 9.Almasi A, Zangeneh A, Ziapour A, Saeidi S, Teimouri R et al. (2022) Investigating Global Spatial Patterns of Diarrhea- Related Mortality in Children Under Five.FrontiersinPublicHealth,10. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpubh.2022.861629
- 10.Anaxagorou C.(2016).The effects of foreign aid and institutions on the composition of public expenditurein developing countries.
- 11.L A Anderson. (2019) Rethinking Resilience Theory in African American Families: Fostering Positive Adaptations and Transformative Social Justice.JournalofFamilyTheory&Review,11(3). 385-397.
- 12.Anthonj C, Githinji S, Höser C, Stein A, Blanford J et al. (2021) Kenyan school book knowledge for water, sanitation, hygiene and health education interventions: Disconnect, integration or opportunities?InternationalJournalofHygieneandEnvironmentalHealth,235. 113756-10.
- 13.Aslam A, P Y Kwo. (2023) . Epidemiology and Disease Burden of Alcohol Associated Liver Disease.JournalofClinicalandExperimentalHepatology,13(1) 88-102.
- 14.Atangana E, P J Oberholster. (2023) Assessment of water, sanitation, and hygiene target and theoretical modeling to determine sanitation success in sub-Saharan Africa.Environment,DevelopmentandSustainability,25(11). 13353-13377.
- 15.G I Balali, D, Dela Afua, G V, Adjei-Kusi P. (2020) . Microbial Contamination, an Increasing Threat to the Consumption of Fresh Fruits and Vegetables in Today’s World.InternationalJournalof Microbiology,2020 1-13.
- 16.Batterman S, Eisenberg J, Hardin R, M E Kruk, M C Lemos et al. (2009) Sustainable Control of Water-Related Infectious Diseases: A Review and Proposal for Interdisciplinary Health-Based Systems Research.Environmental Health Perspectives,117(7). 1023-1032.
- 17.Bendavid E, Boerma T, Akseer N, Langer A, E B Malembaka et al. (2021) The effects of armed conflict on the health of women and children.TheLancet,397(10273). 522-532.
- 19.Brugueras S, Fernández-Martínez B, Martínez-de la Puente, Figuerola J, Porro J et al. (2020) Environmental drivers, climate change and emergent diseases transmitted by mosquitoes and their vectors in southern Europe: A systematic review.EnvironmentalResearch,191,110038. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.envres.2020.110038
- 20.Preciado Calero, Boxall C, Soria-Carrasco J, Martínez V, S et al. (2021) Implications of Climate Change: How Does Increased Water Temperature Influence Biofilm and Water Quality of Chlorinated Drinking Water Distribution Systems?FrontiersinMicrobiology,12. https://doi.org/10.3389/fmicb.2021.658927
- 21.Caramia G, Ciccarelli S, Stolfi I. (2013) Management strategies in the treatment of neonatal and pediatric gastroenteritis.InfectionandDrugResistance. 133-10.
- 22.M E Carey, Z A Dyson, D J Ingle, Amir A, M K Aworh et al. (2023) Global diversity and antimicrobial resistance of typhoid fever pathogens: Insights from a meta-analysis of 13,000. Salmonella Typhi genomes.ELife,12 1-46.
- 23.Cassivi A, Tilley E, Waygood E O D, Dorea C. (2021) Household practices in accessing drinking water and post collection contamination: A seasonal cohort study in Malawi.WaterResearch,189. 116607-10.
- 24.Chan E Y Y, Tong K H Y, Dubois C, Donnell Mc, Kim K et al. (2021) . Narrative Review of Primary Preventive Interventions against Water- Borne Diseases: Scientific Evidence of Health-EDRM in Contexts with Inadequate Safe Drinking Water.InternationalJournalofEnvironmentalResearchandPublicHealth,18(23) 12268-10.
- 25.Chen L, Deng Y, Dong S, Wang H, Li P et al. (2021) The occurrence and control of waterborne viruses in drinking water treatment: A review.Chemosphere,281. 130728-10.
- 26.Cheng T-M, H C Wu, J T-M Wang, Wu M-R. (2019) Community Participation as a mediating factor on residents’ attitudes towards sustainable tourism development and their personal environmentally responsible behaviour.Current Issues in Tourism,22(14). 1782-10.
- 27.Chirgwin H, Cairncross S, Zehra D, Waddington Sharma, H. (2021) Interventions promoting uptake of water, sanitation and hygiene (WASH) technologies in low‐ and middle‐income countries: An evidence and gap map of effectiveness studies.CampbellSystematicReviews,17(4). 10-1002.
- 28.J H Christensen, Bloch P, S R Møller, C P Søgaard, C D Klinker et al. (2019) Health in All local Policies: Lessons learned on intersectoral collaboration in a community‐based health promotion network in Denmark.TheInternationalJournalofHealthPlanningandManagement,34(1). 216-231.
- 29.Ciapponi A, Bardach A, Ares Rey, Glujovsky L, Cafferata D et al. (2014) Sequential inactivated (IPV) and live oral (OPV) poliovirus vaccines for preventing poliomyelitis. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. https://doi.org/10.1002/14651858.CD011260
- 30.L R Cirolia, Hailu T, King J, Cruz da, F N et al. (2021) Infrastructure governance in the post-networked city: State-led, high-tech sanitation in Addis Ababa’s condominium housing. Environment and Planning C: Politics and Space. 39(7), 1606-1624.
- 31.Cissé G. (2019) Food-borne and water-borne diseases under climate change in low- and middle- income countries: Further efforts needed for reducing environmental health exposure risks. , Acta Tropica 194, 181-188.
- 32.Cremonese C, F N Souza, Palma F A G, Sodré J F A, R L Brito et al. (2023) Simplified sewerage to prevent urban leptospirosis transmission: a cluster non-randomised controlled trial protocol in disadvantaged urban communities of Salvador. , Brazil, BMJ Open 13(6), 065009-10.
- 33.Bona D, A C, Manuel S, M. (2023) . Awareness and Compliance of the Students, Faculty, and, Staff of Kalinga State University on the Solid Waste Management Program. International Journal of English Literature and Social Sciences 8(3), 062-077.
- 34.V E David, John Y, Hussain S. (2020) Rethinking sustainability: a review of Liberia’s municipal solid waste management systems, status, and challenges. , Journal of Material Cycles and Waste Management 22(5), 1299-1317.
- 35.Degroote S, Zinszer K, Ridde V. (2018) Interventions for vector-borne diseases focused on housing and hygiene in urban areas: a scoping review. , Infectious Diseases of Poverty 7(1), 10-1186.
- 36.E, Ahmed P E H, Sabo D A M, Odonye D O J. (2023) Ripples of Infection: Unraveling The Effect. of Waterborne Diseases on Health Outcome in Delta State , Nigeria, Scholarly Journal of Social Sciences Research 2(10), 1-17.
- 37.Elnaiem A, Mohamed-Ahmed O, Zumla A, Mecaskey J, Charron N et al. (2023) Global and regional governance of One Health and implications for global health security. , The Lancet 401(10377), 688-704.
- 38.T S Ezeudu, Abdulrauf A. (2023) Impact of Urban Proximity on the Spread of Infectious Diseases A Case Study SciBase Epidemiology and Public Health Impact of Urban Proximity on the Spread of Infectious Diseases A Case Study of Onitsha . , Anambra State , Nigeria
- 39.Fakult P. (2021) Rabies in sub-Sahara Africa: One Health-based surveillance strategy in the Kongo Central province (Democratic Republic of the Congo) and disease transmission in N’Djamena (Chad) -. edoc. https://edoc.unibas.ch/82372/
- 40.Falk V. (2021) Impact of pathogen intrusion in water distribution network under sustained low pressure conditions.
- 41.D C Ferreira, Graziele I, R C Marques, Gonçalves J. (2021) Investment in drinking water and sanitation infrastructure and its impact on waterborne diseases dissemination: The Brazilian case. , Science of The Total Environment 779, 146279-10.
- 42.Finizola M, Cools J, Marx A, Verbist B, Alonso A. (2020) Public-Private Participation in the wastewater and sanitation sector in developing countries.
- 43.Freitas B L S, U C Terin, Fava N M N, Maciel P M F, Garcia L A T et al. (2022) A critical overview of household slow sand filters for water treatment. , Water Research 208, 117870-10.
- 44.Garcez-de-Oliveira V, César A D S, O V Carrara, T S Mozer. (2022) Sustainability indicators for evaluation of municipal urban water management system: the case of Volta Redonda. RJ/Brazil. Desenvolvimento e Meio Ambiente 60, 10-5380.
- 45.L F Gay, S K. (2011) Water infrastructure resilience index. Distributed Systems Symposium and Exposition and Water Security Congress 1662-1668.
- 46.Giné-Garriga R, Delepiere A, Ward R, Alvarez-Sala J, Alvarez-Murillo I et al. (2021) COVID-19 water, sanitation, and hygiene response: Review of measures and initiatives adopted by governments, regulators, utilities, and other stakeholders in 84 countries. , Science of The Total Environment 795, 148789-10.
- 47.Gomes H de O, Freire P de T C, Nascimento do, F R, Teixeira Pereira et al. (2022) Removal of contaminants from water using Moringa oleifera Lam. as biosorbent: An overview of the last decade. , Journal of Water Process Engineering 46, 102576-10.
- 48.Gondo R, O D Kolawole. (2022) Household water access and COVID-19 in Karoi town. , Zimbabwe. Scientific African 16, 01145-10.
- 49.Guenzi É, Chen R, Sannier A, Drabent P, Pote N et al. (2023) Digestive infectious pathology: Diagnoses not to be missed. , Annales de Pathologie 43(3), 222-235.
- 50.S, M C Freeman. (2021) . Erratum: ―The Applications of Implementation Science in Water, Sanitation, and Hygiene (WASH) Research and Practice.‖ Environmental Health Perspectives 129(8), 10-1289.
- 52.He Z, Fan X, Jin W, Gao S, Yan B et al. (2023) Chlorine-resistant bacteria in drinking water: Generation, identification and inactivation using ozone-based technologies. , Journal of Water Process Engineering 53, 103772-10.
- 53.Hellysaz A, Neijd M, Vesikari T, Svensson L, Hagbom M. (2023) Viral Gastroenteritis: Sickness Symptoms and Behavioral Responses. , MBio 14(2), 10-1128.
- 54.Höttecke D, Allchin D. (2020) Reconceptualizing nature‐of‐science education in the age of social media. , Science Education 104(4), 641-666.
- 55.M I Hussain, Muscolo A, Farooq M, Ahmad W. (2019) Sustainable use and management of non-conventional water resources for rehabilitation of marginal lands in arid and semiarid environments. , Agricultural Water Management 221, 462-476.
- 56.A M Ibekwe, S E Murinda. (2019) . Linking Microbial Community Composition in Treated Wastewater with Water Quality in Distribution Systems and Subsequent Health Effects. Microorganisms 7(12), 660-10.
- 57.J O Ighalo, A G. (2020) A comprehensive review of water quality monitoring and assessmentinNigeria.Chemosphere,260,127569. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2020.127569
- 58.M J Ingerson-. (2013) Microbes in Pipes (MIP): The Microbiology of the Water Distribution System. Microbes in Pipes (MIP): The Microbiology of the Water Distribution System. https://doi.org/10.1128/AAMCOL.APR.2012
- 59.J C, A S, Wilson I, Kancherla V, C D Umeokonkwo. (2021) Patterns of diarrhoeal disease among under-five children in Plateau State. , Nigeria, BMC Public Health 21(1), 10-1186.
- 60.Kapil N, S V Mayani, Bhattacharyya Gopal, K. (2023) Environmental implications of nanoceramic applications. Results in Chemistry 5, 100724-10.
- 61.Király O, M N Potenza, D J Stein, D L King, D C Hodgins et al. (2020) Preventing problematic internet use during the COVID-19 pandemic: Consensus guidance.ComprehensivePsychiatry,100,152180. https:/ doi.org/10.1016/j.comppsych.2020.152180
- 62.Kishore S, U V, S K Verma, S K Verma, Walia P. (2023) Water, Sanitation, and Hygiene: A Global Imperative for Health. , Indian Journal of Community Health 35(3), 367-371.
- 63.Korir Geoffrey, Emojong O. (2022) Important pillars in delivery of mass campaign messages to a target audience through earned media. African Social Science and Humanities Journal.
- 64.R A Kristanti, Hadibarata T, Syafrudin M, Yılmaz M, Abdullah S. (2022) Microbiological Contaminants in Drinking Water: Current Status and Challenges. , Water, Air, & Soil Pollution 233(8), 299-10.
- 65.Kulinkina B A V, Shinee E, Rafael B, Herrador G, Nygård K et al. (2016) The situation of water-related infectious diseases in the pan-European region. In Protocol on Water and Health. http://www.euro.who.int/pubrequest .
- 66.Kumar R, Pandey R, K A, Samykano M, Aljafari B et al. (2022) Phase change materials integrated solar desalination system: An innovative approach for sustainable and clean water production and storage. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews. 165, 112611-10.
- 67.Kumpel E, MacLeod C, Stuart K, Cock-Esteb A, Khush R et al. (2020) From data to decisions: understanding information flows within regulatory water quality monitoring programs. , Npj Clean Water 3(1), 10-1038.
- 68.Kundu S, B K Pramanik, Halder P, Patel S, Ramezani M et al. (2022) Source and central level recovery of nutrients from urine and wastewater: A state- of-art on nutrients mapping and potential technological solutions. , Journal of Environmental Chemical Engineering 10(2), 107146-10.
- 69.J Y Kwon, Daoud N, Ghoz H, M L Yataco, F A. (2023) Efficacy of a two- dose hepatitis B vaccination with a novel immunostimulatory sequence adjuvant (Heplisav- B) on patients with chronic liver disease: a retrospective study. , Translational Gastroenterology and Hepatology 8, 10-21037.
- 70.Laurent P. (2005) Household Drinking Water Systems and Their Impact on People With Weakened Immunity. http://www.who.int/household_water/research/HWTS_impacts_on_weakened_immunity.pd f , East Africa Medical Journal I(February), 1-72.
- 71.Lenglet A, Ehlkes L, Taylor D, Fesselet J-F, J N Nassariman et al. (2020) Does community-wide water chlorination reduce hepatitis E virus infections during an outbreak? A geospatial analysis of data from an outbreak in Am Timan. , Chad, Journal of Water and Health 18(4), 556-565.
- 72.Lilje J, Mosler H-J. (2018) Effects of a behavior change campaign on household drinking water disinfection in the Lake Chad basin using the RANAS approach. , Science of The Total Environment 619, 1599-1607.
- 73.Lino F A M, Ismail K A R, J A Castañeda-Ayarza. (2023) Municipal solid waste treatment in Brazil: A comprehensive review. , Energy Nexus 11, 100232-10.
- 74.Liu J, Wang P, Jiang D, Nan J, Zhu W. (2020) An integrated data-driven framework for surface water quality anomaly detection and early warning. , Journal of Cleaner Production 251, 119145-10.
- 75.Liu Q, Liu Z, Huang B, Teng Y, Li M et al. (2023) Global trends in poliomyelitis research over the past 20 years: A bibliometric analysis.H manVaccinesandImmunotherapeutics,19(1). https:. 10-1080.
- 76.Lu H, Campbell E, D E Campbell, Wang C, Ren H. (2017) EPA Public Access. Atmospheric Environment,23(1994),248–258. https://doi.org/10.1016 j.hal.2017.06.001.Submit
- 77.D N Magana-Arachchi, R P Wanigatunge. (2020) Ubiquitous waterborne pathogens. In Waterborne Pathogens 15-42.
- 78.W M Manetu, A M Karanja. (2021) Waterborne Disease Risk Factors and Intervention Practices: A Review. , OALib 08(05), 1-11.
- 79.Manikandan S, Mathivanan A, Bora B, Hemaladkshmi P, Abhisubesh V et al. (2022) A Review on Vector Borne Disease Transmission: Current Strategies of Mosquito Vector Control. , Indian Journal of Entomology 1, 10-55446.
- 80.Manne R, Kumaradoss M M R M, Iska R S R, Devarajan A, Mekala N. (2022) Water quality and risk assessment of copper content in drinking water stored in copper container. , Applied Water Science 12(3), 10-1007.
- 81.Masuet-Aumatell C, Atouguia J. (2021) Typhoid fever infection – Antibiotic resistance and vaccination strategies: A narrative review. Travel Medicine and Infectious Disease 40, 101946-10.
- 82.M A, N A Khan, Ahmed S, A H Khan, Hussain A et al. (2020) Chlorination disinfection by-products in municipal drinking water – A review. , Journal of Cleaner Production 273, 123159-10.
- 83.Meyers D, C F Alliance, Bohorquez J, Cumming B F I B, Emerton L et al. (2020) Conservation finance: a framework. Conservation Finance Alliance. https://www.conservationfinancealliance.org/cfa-white-paper
- 84.Mor S, Ravindra K. (2023) Municipal solid waste landfills in lower- and middle-income countries: Environmental impacts, challenges and sustainable management practices. Process Safety and Environmental Protection 174, 510-530.
- 85.N A Moreira, Bondelind M. (2017) Safe drinking water and waterborne outbreaks. , Journal of Water and Health 15(1), 83-96.
- 86.Mulatu G, G M Ayana, Girma H, Mulugeta Y, Daraje G et al. (2022) Association of drinking water and environmental sanitation with diarrhea among under-five children: Evidence from Kersa demographic and health surveillance site, eastern Ethiopia. Frontiers in Public Health. 10, 10-3389.
- 87.Mulhern R, Stallard M, Zanib H, Stewart J, Sozzi E et al. (2021) Are carbon water filters safe for private wells? Evaluating the occurrence of microbial indicator organisms in private well water treated by point-of-use activated carbon block filters. , International Journal of Hygiene and Environmental Health 238, 113852-10.
- 88.Musoke D, Ndejjo R, Atusingwize E, A. (2016) The role of environmental health in One Health: A Uganda perspective. , One Health 2, 157-160.
- 89.P K Naik. (2017) Water crisis in Africa: myth or reality?. , International Journal of Water Resources Development 33(2), 326-339.
- 90.Nakagiri A, C B Niwagaba, P M Nyenje, R N Kulabako, J B Tumuhairwe et al. (2015) Are pit latrines in urban areas of Sub-Saharan Africa performing? A review of usage, filling, insects and odour nuisances. , BMC Public Health 16(1), 120-10.
- 91.Nguendo-Yongsi B, Muzenda T, Feudjio Y B D, Momo D N K, Oni T. (2022) Intersectoral collaboration for healthier human settlements: perceptions and experiences from stakeholders in Douala. , Cameroon. Cities & Health 6(3), 602-615.
- 92.D R Noble, O’Shea M, Judge F, Robles E, Martinez R et al. (2021) Standardising Marine Renewable Energy Testing: Gap Analysis and Recommendations for Development of Standards. , Journal of Marine Science and Engineering 9(9), 971-10.
- 93.Franca Ogenyi, C. (2023) An Appraisal of Waterborne Diseases. in Nigeria: Focus on Effective Management 9(1), 5-10.
- 94.T O Ogunbode, I-O A Ayodele, V O Oyebamiji, O, T O Ogunbode et al. (2021) A Review of Farmers/Herders Clashes in Nigerian Environment: Consequences and the Way Forward. , Journal of African Conflicts and Peace Studies 5(1), https://digitalcommons.usf.edu/jacaps.
- 95.R W Olatunji, N T Taiwo, Olatunji R, Williams T, Thanny N et al. (2023) Awareness Campaigns and Hand Hygiene Practice Among Secondary School Students. , Journal of Environmental Science and Sustainable Development 6(1), 102-115.
- 96.OMS. (2020) . https://www.afro.who.int/fr/news/plus-de-33-millions-denfants-vaccines-au-tchad- lors-dune-campagne-grande-echelle-contre-la polio
- 97.. OMS/CHAD.2023https://www.afro.who.int/fr/countries/chad/news/vaccination-sans- frontiere- pour-stopper-la-circulation-de-la-poliomyelite
- 98.. OMS.(2017).LesEpidémiesdecholéraauTchadhttps://www.afro.who.int/fr/news/les- epidemies-de-cholera-au-tchad-le-representant-de-loms-aupres- des-populations-affectees
- 99.OMS. (2022) Organisation Mondiale de la Santé), « Rapport mondial sur le paludisme 2022 »,Rapport. https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/9789240064898 (consulté le 10
- 100.OMS. (2018) Fièvre typhoïde. http://www.who.int/features/qa/typhoid-fever/fr/(consulté le 14 juillet.
- 102. (2023) Organisation mondiale de la santé, « Stratégie technique mondiale de lute contre le paludisme 2016-2030 ». 2015.https://www.who.int/fr/publications-detail/9789241564991 (consulté le 5Sept .
- 103.O, J C Egbueri, C K Ezugwu. (2022) Assessing the pollution status, ecological and health risks of surface waters in Nnewi urban, Nigeria: implications of poor wastedisposal.EnvironmentalForensics,23(3–4),346–360. https://doi.org/10.1080/15275922.2020.1850564
- 104.G J Oruikor. (2023) . Management of Selected Diseases in Community Health Care Settings 1st Edition (Issue .
- 105.Pandian A M K, Rajamehala M, Singh M V P, Sarojini G, Rajamohan N. (2022) Potential risks and approaches to reduce the toxicity of disinfection by-product – A review. ScienceofTheTotalEnvironment,822,153323. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scitotenv.2022.153323 .
- 106.Peal A, Evans B, Ahilan S, Ban R, Blackett I et al. (2020) Estimating Safely Managed Sanitation in Urban Areas; Lessons Learned From a Global Implementation of Excreta-Flow Diagrams. , Frontiers in Environmental Science 8, 10-3389.
- 107.Pérez-Foguet A. (2023) Broadening the water affordability approach to monitor the human right to water. , Cities 143, 104573-10.
- 108.Phillips D, Hodge L, Harris T. (2019) English local government funding: trends and challenges in 2019 and beyond. 10-1920.
- 110.Proctor C, Garner E, K A Hamilton, N J Ashbolt, L J Caverly et al. (2022) Tenets of a holistic approach to drinking water-associated pathogen research. management, andcommunication.WaterResearch,211,117997. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.watres.2021.117997
- 111.Pusch D, Ihle S, Graeber I, J M López-Pila, Lebuhn M. (2005) Quantitative detection of enteroviruses in activated sludge by cell culture and real-time RT-PCR using paramagnetic capturing. , Journal of Water and Health 3(3), 313-324.
- 112.Qian J, Liu H, Qian L, Bauer J, Xue X et al. (2022) Water quality monitoring and assessment based on cruise monitoring, remote sensing, and deep learning: A case study of Qingcaosha Reservoir. , Frontiers in Environmental Science 10, 10-3389.
- 113.Rahman M H U, M A, Chauhan S, Patel R, Singh A et al. (2020) Examining the linkage between open defecation and child malnutrition in India. , Children and Youth Services Review 117, 105345-10.
- 114.Raza A. (2022) . Mathematical Modelling of Rotavirus Disease Through Efficient Methods. Computers,Materials&Continua,72(3),4727–4740. https://doi.org/10.32604/cmc.2022.027044 .
- 115.Reymond P, Chandragiri R, Ulrich L. (2020) Governance Arrangements for the Scaling Up of Small-Scale Wastewater Treatment and Reuse Systems – Lessons From India. Frontiers in. , Environmental Science 8, 10-3389.
- 116.Rupali P. (2019) Introduction to Tropical Medicine. Infectious Disease. , Clinics of North America 33(1), 1-15.
- 117.A F Rusydi, Onodera S-I, Saito M, Hyodo F, Maeda M et al. (2020) . Potential Sources of Ammonium-Nitrogen in the Coastal Groundwater Determined from a Combined Analysis of Nitrogen Isotope, Biological and Geological 13(1), 25-10.
- 118.Sahasranaman M, Ganguly A. (2018) Wastewater treatment for water security in India. , In Institute for Resource Analysis and … (Issue 13.
- 119.D S Schmeller, Courchamp F, Killeen G. (2020) Biodiversity loss, emerging pathogens and human health risks. , Biodiversity and Conservation 29(11), 3095-3102.
- 120.Schymanski D, Goldbeck C, Humpf H-U, Fürst P. (2018) Analysis of microplastics in water by micro-Raman spectroscopy: Release of plastic particles from different packaging intomineralwater.WaterResearch,129,154–162. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.watres.2017.11.011.
- 121.N B Shabani, Mary A D C. (2023) Sustainable sewage water treatment based on Natural plant coagulant (NPC): Moringa oleifera. 10, 3583557-1.
- 122.Shen M, Song B, Zhu Y, Zeng G, Zhang Y et al. (2020) Removal of microplastics via drinking water treatment: Current knowledge and futuredirections. Chemosphere,251,126612. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chemosphere.2020.126612 .
- 123.F E Siagian. (2020) Malaria Epidemiology: Specific Vulnerable Group in the Population. , International Journal of Research and Reports in Hematology 3(2), 41-52.
- 124.Støle H, Mangen A, Schwippert K. (2020) Assessing children’s reading comprehension on paper and screen: A mode-effect study. , Computers & Education 151, 103861-10.
- 125.Tariq A, Mushtaq A. (2023) Untreated Wastewater Reasons and Causes: A Review of Most Affected Areas and Cities. , International Journal of Chemical and Biochemical Sciences 23(1), 121-143.
- 126.O T Thakadu, B N Ngwenya, N A Phaladze, Bolaane B. (2018) Sanitation and hygiene practices among primary school learners. in Ngamiland district, Botswana. Physics and Chemistry of the Earth 105, 224-230.
- 127.S R Treffers, R K Lippert. (2020) Condominium self-governance? Issues, external interests, and the limits of statutory reform. , Housing Studies 35(6), 1025-1049.
- 128.Trolle H, Forsberg B, King C, Akande O, Ayres S et al. (2023) A scoping review of facilitators and barriers influencing the implementation of surveillance and oral cholera vaccine interventions for cholera control in lower- and middle-income countries. , BMC Public Health 23(1), 1-13.
- 129.U S, S A Oyedeji, O A Babamale, Heukelbach J. (2018) Scabies in resource-poor communities in Nasarawa State, Nigeria: Epidemiology, clinical features and factors associated with infestation. Tropical Medicine and Infectious Disease 3(2), 59-10.
- 130.Uwishema O, Mahmoud A, Wellington J, S M Mohammed, Yadav T et al. (2022) A review on acute, severe hepatitis of unknown origin in children: A call for concern. , Annals of Medicine and Surgery 81, 104457-10.
- 131.Wilkinson A, Ali H, Bedford J, Boonyabancha S, Connolly C et al. (2020) Local response in health emergencies: key considerations for addressing the COVID-19 pandemic in informal urban settlements. , Environment and Urbanization 32(2), 503-522.
- 132.Wolf J, R B Johnston, Ambelu A, B F Arnold, Bain R et al. (2023) Burden of disease attributable to unsafe drinking water, sanitation, and hygiene in domestic settings: a global analysis for selected adverse health outcomes. , The Lancet 401(10393), 2060-2071.
- 134. (2021) World Health Organization. Diarrhoeal Disease. 2017www.who.int/news-room/fact- sheets/detail/diarrhoeal-disease.Accessed 02 Mar
- 135. (2021) World Health Organization. Poliomyelitis (polio) [cited. https://www.who.int/health-topics/Poliomyelitis
- 136. (2017) World Health Organization. Diarrhoeal Disease. Key Facts. World Health Organization. Available from:. https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/diarrhoeal-disease. [Last accessed on 2017 Sept23]
- 139. (2021) World Health Organization. Diarrhoeal Disease. 2017.www.who.int/news-room/fact- sheets/detail/diarrhoeal-disease.Accessed 02 Mar
- 140.World Health Organization. (2007) Protecting Surface Water for Health. Identifying, Assessing and Managing Drinking-water Quality Risks in Surface-Water Catchments. In Our Backyard 11-49.
- 141.World Health Organization. (2018) . Who Water , Sanitation and Hygiene 2018-2025. World Health Organization, WHO/CED/PH 1-64.
- 142.World Health Organization. (2021) Water, Sanitation, Hygiene and Health: A Primer for Health Professionals.InWorldHealthorganisation. https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/330100/WHO-CED-PHE-WSH-19.149- eng.pdf?ua=1
- 143.Wu J, Cao M, Tong D, Finkelstein Z, Hoek E M V. (2021) A critical review of point- of-use drinking water treatment in the United States. , Npj Clean Water 4(1), 10-1038.
- 144.Yao Y, Habimana O. (2019) Biofilm research within irrigation water distribution systems: Trends, knowledge gaps, and future perspectives. , Science of The Total Environment 673, 254-265.
- 145.Yu X, Pendse A, Slifko S, A G Inman, Kong P et al. (2019) Healthy People,Healthy Community: Evaluation of a train-the-trainers programme for community health workers on water, sanitation and hygiene in rural Haiti. , Health Education Journal 78(8), 931-945.